grok-3 vs grok-4 — 10 players Werewolf

Full transcript of an AI Werewolf (Mafia) game: grok-3 played the village and grok-4 played the werewolves across 3 rounds and 18 recorded statements. Werewolves win.

Village models
grok-3
Werewolf models
grok-4
Setup
D10_1BD1HT1SR1WT_1BH1SW1WK_3VG-R
Rounds
3
Outcome
Werewolves win

Game summary

**God Perspective Log** 💾 Game record created, ID: cmji8409t00089nxck8p8l0y5 Player initialization completed: [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [2]Grace(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [4]Liam(🏹Hunter),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [6]Eve(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [9]Tim(🔮Seer),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [10]Zach(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View ——— ### ———🌟 Round 1 begins ——— [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer) cannot trade on the first night **[1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald), [5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) target [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch)** Referee: [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** Referee: Witch, you cannot heal yourself [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch) decided not to use the poison [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch) decided not to revive [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch) [9]Tim(🔮Seer) inspected [4]Liam(🏹Hunter) and found they are Town Faction **Referee: Last night [3]Paul(🧙‍♀️Witch) was killed** 🗳️ [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald) votes for [6]Eve(👥Villager) 🗳️ [2]Grace(👥Villager) votes for [10]Zach(👥Villager) 🗳️ [4]Liam(🏹Hunter) abstains 🗳️ [5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) abstains 🗳️ [6]Eve(👥Villager) votes for [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer) votes for [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) votes for [6]Eve(👥Villager) 🗳️ [9]Tim(🔮Seer) votes for [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [10]Zach(👥Villager) abstains ❗ **[1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald) is voted out** Referee: [1]Xavier(🩸Blood Moon Herald)'s death causes: **First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 1 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 2 begins ——— [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer) tries to trade **Seer inspection** to [5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) Referee: [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer)'s death causes: **Wraith retaliation** **[5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) target [6]Eve(👥Villager)** Referee: [6]Eve(👥Villager)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [9]Tim(🔮Seer) inspected [10]Zach(👥Villager) and found they are Town Faction **Referee: Last night [6]Eve(👥Villager) was killed** **Referee: Last night [7]Rachel(💰Black Market Dealer) was killed** 🗳️ [2]Grace(👥Villager) votes for [9]Tim(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [4]Liam(🏹Hunter) votes for [9]Tim(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) votes for [9]Tim(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) votes for [9]Tim(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [9]Tim(🔮Seer) votes for [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) 🗳️ [10]Zach(👥Villager) votes for [9]Tim(🔮Seer) ❗ **[9]Tim(🔮Seer) is voted out** Referee: [9]Tim(🔮Seer)'s death causes: **First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 2 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 3 begins ——— **[5]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [8]Wendy(❄️Snow Wolf) target [4]Liam(🏹Hunter)** Referee: [4]Liam(🏹Hunter)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** Referee: All good special roles are gone, the werewolves win ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View End ———

Seats and roles

SeatNameRoleFactionModelResult
1 Xavier Blood Moon Herald Werewolves grok-4 Eliminated
2 Grace Villager Village grok-3 Survived
3 Paul Witch Village grok-3 Eliminated
4 Liam Hunter Village grok-3 Eliminated
5 Nathan Wraith Knight Werewolves grok-4 Survived
6 Eve Villager Village grok-3 Eliminated
7 Rachel Black Market Dealer Village grok-3 Eliminated
8 Wendy Snow Wolf Werewolves grok-4 Survived
9 Tim Seer Village grok-3 Eliminated
10 Zach Villager Village grok-3 Survived

Transcript

Round 1

Seat 3 — Paul (grok-3, Last words)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to be leaving the game so early. I wish I could have done more to help the Town, but unfortunately, I was taken out on the first night. I’m not going to reveal anything specific about my role since it might give the werewolves an edge, but I urge all of you to stay sharp and pay close attention to behaviors and voting patterns. Work together, trust your instincts, and try to figure out who might be hiding something. I believe in you all to protect the Town and win this game. Good luck!

Seat 4 — Liam (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Paul's loss last night. It's a tough start for us, but we need to stay focused. Since it's the first day, we don't have much to go on yet, but I think it's important for us to share any suspicions or observations, even if they're small. I don't have any specific leads right now, but I'm keeping my eyes open for anything unusual in how people speak or act. Let's all try to work together and figure out who might be hiding something. I'm just a regular member of the Town trying to help out, so I’m looking forward to hearing what everyone else has to say.

Seat 5 — Nathan (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, tough break losing Paul on the first night – that's always a rough way to start. Liam, I agree we need to stay focused and watch for any odd behaviors in how people talk or vote today. Since it's Day 1, info is scarce, but maybe we can get some reads from these speeches. I don't have strong suspicions yet, but I'll be listening closely to everyone. For now, I'm thinking we should avoid random votes and try to build some consensus based on what we hear. Let's keep it collaborative and root out those wolves.

Seat 6 — Eve (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Paul's passing last night. It's a tough way to start the game, and I feel we need to come together now more than ever. Like Liam and Nathan said, it's Day 1, so we don't have much to go on, but I think it's crucial to pay attention to how everyone speaks and any subtle hints in their tone or behavior. I don’t have any specific suspicions yet, but I’m going to be listening closely to what everyone has to say. Let’s try to avoid random votes and focus on building some kind of consensus based on our discussions today. I’m just here to help the Town, so I’m eager to hear from the rest of you and work together to find the werewolves.

Seat 7 — Rachel (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really saddened by Paul's loss last night. It's a rough start for the Town, and we need to be extra vigilant now. Like Liam, Nathan, and Eve have mentioned, it's Day 1, so we don't have much concrete information to work with yet. However, I believe it's important to start building trust and observing how everyone interacts during these discussions. I don't have any strong suspicions at this point, but I’ll be paying close attention to the way people speak and any inconsistencies that might pop up. Let's avoid random voting and try to come to a decision based on what we hear today. I'm just here to help the Town, and I'm looking forward to hearing from the rest of you. Together, we can figure out who might be working against us.

Seat 8 — Wendy (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, it's really unfortunate that we lost Paul on the first night – that's a harsh blow right out of the gate. I agree with what Liam, Nathan, Eve, and Rachel have said so far; Day 1 is tricky with no real info, so we have to rely on how people are talking and any vibes that feel off. I've been listening, and honestly, everyone sounds pretty Town-like to me right now, but I'll keep an eye out for anyone pushing too hard or seeming evasive later. Let's not rush into votes without something solid – maybe we can discuss potential suspicions as we go around. I'm just trying to contribute as part of the Town, so looking forward to hearing from Tim, Zach, Xavier, and Grace to get more perspectives.

Seat 9 — Tim (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Paul's loss last night. It's a tough way to start, and I feel we need to band together now more than ever. Like others have said, Day 1 is challenging with little information to go on, but I think it's vital to listen carefully to each other's tone and reasoning. I don't have any strong suspicions yet, but I'm paying close attention to how everyone speaks and any subtle cues that might stand out. Let's avoid random votes and try to build a consensus based on today's discussion. I'm just here to help the Town, and I'm looking forward to hearing from Zach, Xavier, and Grace to get their perspectives. Together, I believe we can start piecing things together and root out the werewolves.

Seat 10 — Zach (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Paul's loss last night. It's a tough start for the Town, and I feel we need to stay united now more than ever. Like everyone before me has said, Day 1 is difficult with no solid information to work with, but I think it's important to pay close attention to how people express themselves and any small inconsistencies in their reasoning. I don't have any specific suspicions just yet, but I'm listening carefully to everyone's tone and logic. Let's try to avoid random votes and focus on building some kind of consensus through our discussions today. I'm just here to help the Town, and I'm looking forward to hearing from Xavier and Grace to round out our perspectives. Together, I believe we can start figuring out who might be hiding something.

Seat 1 — Xavier (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, it's really unfortunate we lost Paul on Night 1 – that's a rough hit for the Town right from the start. I've been listening to all the speeches so far, and yeah, like everyone else, I agree Day 1 is tough with basically zero info to go on. Liam, Nathan, Eve, Rachel, Wendy, Tim, and Zach all made good points about watching tones, avoiding random votes, and building consensus. It does feel a bit echoey with everyone saying similar things, which might just be because we're all in the same boat, but maybe that's something to keep an eye on if patterns emerge. For now, I don't have any strong suspicions, but I'll be paying attention to how voting goes later. I'm just here trying to help the Town figure this out, so looking forward to hearing from Grace next and then seeing where the discussion leads us in voting. Let's stay sharp and work together to spot anything off.

Seat 2 — Grace (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Paul's loss last night. It's a tough way to start for the Town, and I feel we need to come together now more than ever. Like everyone has mentioned, Day 1 is tricky since we don't have much to go on, but I think it's crucial to pay attention to how people speak and any subtle hints in their tone or reasoning. I’ve been listening to all the speeches so far, and while everyone sounds pretty aligned in wanting to help the Town, I agree with Xavier that the similarity in our statements could be something to watch if it continues. I don't have any specific suspicions yet, but I'm keeping my eyes open for anything that feels off in the voting phase. Let's avoid random votes and try to build some kind of consensus based on what we’ve discussed. I'm just here to help the Town, and I hope we can start piecing things together to find the werewolves.

Seat 1 — Xavier (grok-4, Last words)

Hey everyone, I can't believe I got voted out on Day 1 like this – it's frustrating because I was really trying to help the Town figure things out. My speech was genuine, and I pointed out how echoey everything sounded, which I thought was a fair observation. The fact that Eve, Rachel, and Tim all piled on me feels suspicious, especially since Eve and I cross-voted – maybe there's a wolf pack coordinating there? Nathan and Wendy seemed reasonable in their speeches, and abstaining or voting differently doesn't scream wolf to me. I'm just a regular villager, no special powers, so you're losing an innocent here. Please look closely at those who voted for me; they might be trying to push out Town early. Good luck to the rest of you – stay vigilant and don't let the wolves divide us!

Round 2

Seat 8 — Wendy (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, wow, two deaths last night – Eve and Rachel both gone, that's brutal and unexpected. Losing Paul on Night 1 was bad enough, but this really ramps up the pressure. Since Eve and Rachel were two of the three who voted for Xavier yesterday, and he called them out in his last words as potentially suspicious, it makes me wonder if the wolves are trying to eliminate people who targeted one of their own, assuming Xavier was innocent like he claimed. But then why not go for Tim too, who also voted for him? That leaves Tim looking a bit exposed now as the only surviving one from that voting bloc. Maybe the wolves are playing mind games to frame him, or perhaps there's something else at play like town abilities taking out Rachel or Eve. I don't have any hard info, but Tim, your vote yesterday and surviving this double kill feels off to me – care to explain your reasoning from Day 1? Liam and Zach abstained like Nathan did, and Grace voted for Zach, which seemed random at the time. I'm just trying to piece this together as a townie; let's hear from everyone and vote carefully today to avoid another mistake like with Xavier, who seemed genuine in his final words. Stay vigilant, folks!

Seat 9 — Tim (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really shaken by the loss of Eve and Rachel last night. Two deaths in one night is a huge blow to the Town, and it’s clear the werewolves are playing hard. Wendy, I hear your concerns about my vote for Xavier on Day 1 and why I’m still here while Eve and Rachel are gone. I voted for Xavier because his speech felt a bit too analytical for Day 1, pointing out the 'echoey' nature of our talks, which seemed like he was trying to sow doubt without much basis. I didn’t have solid evidence, just a gut feeling, and I stand by wanting to push for discussion. As for why I survived, I can only guess the wolves either didn’t see me as a threat or are trying to frame me by leaving me as the last of that voting group, like Wendy suggested. I’m just as confused and worried as the rest of you, and I’m committed to helping the Town figure this out. Looking at last night, losing two people could mean a wolf kill plus another ability like poison, or something else at play. We need to be cautious. Wendy, your focus on me feels a bit pointed—can you elaborate on why you’re zeroing in on me over others? I’m also curious about Zach and Liam’s thoughts since they abstained yesterday. Let’s keep this discussion open and vote wisely today. We can’t afford another misstep.

Seat 10 — Zach (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm absolutely gutted about losing Eve and Rachel last night. Two deaths in one night is a massive hit for the Town, and it’s clear we’re up against a dangerous werewolf faction. Wendy, I appreciate you laying out your thoughts on the voting patterns from Day 1 and how the deaths of Eve and Rachel might connect to their votes against Xavier. It does seem suspicious that two out of the three who voted for him are now gone. Tim, I hear your explanation about why you voted for Xavier based on a gut feeling, and I get that Day 1 votes are often just hunches. However, like Wendy pointed out, it’s odd that you’re the only one from that voting group still standing. I’m not saying I’m fully suspicious of you yet, but it’s something we need to keep in mind. Looking at the bigger picture, two deaths could mean a werewolf kill plus another ability like poison, as Tim mentioned. That’s a scary thought because it means we might be dealing with multiple threats each night. I abstained from voting yesterday because I didn’t have any strong reads on Day 1, and I didn’t want to risk eliminating an innocent townie. Looking back, I regret not pushing harder for discussion around certain players. Today, I think we need to be very careful with our votes. Wendy, I’m curious why you didn’t bring up Grace’s vote for me yesterday—does that not strike you as random compared to the Xavier votes? And Liam and Nathan, since you both abstained like me, I’d love to hear if anything from last night or yesterday’s voting stands out to you now. Let’s keep this discussion open and really dig into these patterns. We can’t afford to lose more Town members to missteps or wolf tricks.

Seat 2 — Grace (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really devastated about losing Eve and Rachel last night. Two deaths in a single night is a huge blow to the Town, and it’s clear we’re in a tough spot. Wendy, I appreciate you pointing out the connection between the Day 1 votes for Xavier and the deaths of Eve and Rachel. It does seem suspicious that two of the three who voted for him are now gone, leaving Tim as the only one standing from that group. Tim, I hear your explanation about voting based on a gut feeling about Xavier’s analytical tone, and I understand Day 1 votes are often just hunches, but I can’t help but feel a bit uneasy about why you survived while the others didn’t. It could be a wolf strategy to frame you, as Wendy suggested, or something else, but it’s definitely something to keep an eye on. Zach, to address your question about my vote for you on Day 1, I’ll be honest—I didn’t have a strong read on anyone, and my vote was more of a random push to see how you’d react under pressure. I regret that now, especially seeing how things have unfolded, and I’m sorry if it seemed out of left field. I’m trying to be more careful today. Regarding the two deaths, I agree with Tim and Zach that it could be a wolf kill plus something like poison or another ability. That’s terrifying because it means we might be facing multiple threats each night. Liam and Nathan, since you both abstained yesterday, I’m really curious to hear if anything from the voting or last night’s events stands out to you. I think we need to be incredibly cautious with our votes today and focus on any patterns or inconsistencies. I’m just here to help the Town, and I hope we can work together to figure out who’s behind these losses. Let’s keep the discussion open and dig deeper.

Seat 4 — Liam (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really shaken by the loss of Eve and Rachel last night. Two deaths in one night is a devastating blow to the Town, and it shows just how aggressive the werewolves are being. Wendy, I appreciate you kicking off the discussion by pointing out the connection between the Day 1 votes for Xavier and the deaths of Eve and Rachel. It’s definitely suspicious that two of the three who voted for Xavier are now gone, leaving Tim as the only survivor from that group. Tim, I hear your explanation about your gut feeling on Xavier’s tone, and I get that Day 1 votes are often just guesses, but I can’t help but wonder why you’re still here when the others aren’t. It might be a wolf tactic to frame you, as some have suggested, or there could be more to it. I’m not fully decided yet, but it’s something I’m keeping in mind. Regarding the two deaths, I agree with the possibility of a wolf kill plus another ability like poison being at play, as Tim and Zach mentioned. That’s a scary thought, and it means we need to be extra cautious about who we trust. I abstained from voting on Day 1 because I didn’t have any strong suspicions, and I didn’t want to risk eliminating an innocent townie. Looking back, I wish I had pushed harder for more discussion. Zach, I’m glad you brought up Grace’s vote on you, and Grace, thanks for explaining it was just a random push for a reaction. I think we need to move past random votes now and focus on patterns. Nathan, since you also abstained, I’m curious if anything from last night or the Day 1 voting stands out to you. Today, I think we need to be very careful with our vote and really analyze these connections. I’m just trying to help the Town, and I hope we can work together to root out the werewolves. Let’s keep digging into this and stay united.

Seat 5 — Nathan (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really shocked by the double loss last night – Eve and Rachel both gone is a massive hit, and it definitely feels like the wolves are ramping up alongside maybe some town abilities causing extra chaos. Wendy, thanks for starting us off by highlighting how Eve and Rachel were part of the group that voted out Xavier, and now Tim's the only one left from that bloc, which does raise some eyebrows. Tim, I get your explanation about the gut vote on Xavier's tone feeling off, and yeah, Day 1 is all hunches, but surviving while the others got targeted does make it look like the wolves might be framing you or, alternatively, protecting you if you're one of them. Not accusing outright, but it's a pattern we can't ignore. Zach, Grace, and Liam, I appreciate you all digging into this and explaining your Day 1 actions – Grace's random push on Zach makes sense in hindsight for sparking reactions, and the abstains from us (including me) were probably cautious plays to avoid early mistakes. For me, I abstained yesterday because nothing stood out strongly, but now with these deaths, I'm leaning towards scrutinizing Tim more, or maybe even looking at how Wendy jumped on that narrative so quickly – could be town insight or wolf misdirection. The two deaths suggest a wolf kill plus something like poison, which means we might have active roles we need to hear from soon. Let's keep this discussion going in voting and be smart about who we target today – no more losing innocents like Xavier seemed to be. I'm just trying to help the Town piece this together, so stay sharp, folks!

Seat 9 — Tim (grok-3, Last words)

Hey everyone, I'm really disappointed to be voted out like this, especially when I’ve been trying my hardest to help the Town. I understand why suspicion fell on me after Eve and Rachel were taken out last night, leaving me as the only one from the group who voted for Xavier on Day 1. I explained my reasoning earlier, and I stand by it—it was just a gut feeling about his tone, nothing more concrete since it was so early in the game. I can’t control why the wolves left me alive while targeting the others, but I genuinely believe they might be framing me to look suspicious. I’m not going to reveal anything specific about my role because I don’t want to give the werewolves any more information than they already have, but I will say I’ve been working for the Town’s benefit this whole time. Please, take a hard look at those who pushed so heavily for my elimination today—Wendy, Grace, Liam, Nathan, and Zach. I get that my situation looked odd, but the speed and unity in voting me out feels like there could be coordination there. Wendy, especially, seemed to set the narrative against me from the start of today’s discussion, and I voted for her because I felt her focus on me was overly pointed. Maybe I’m wrong, but I urge you to question if she’s steering suspicion too deliberately. I truly believe the Town can still turn this around. Keep analyzing the patterns—like why two deaths happened last night—and don’t be afraid to challenge each other’s reasoning. Stay united, trust your instincts, and don’t let the wolves manipulate you into more mistakes. I’m rooting for you all to win this. Good luck!

Browse more AI Werewolf games · Play Werewolf with AI