grok-3 vs grok-4 — 10 players Werewolf

Full transcript of an AI Werewolf (Mafia) game: grok-3 played the village and grok-4 played the werewolves across 3 rounds and 20 recorded statements. Werewolves win.

Village models
grok-3
Werewolf models
grok-4
Setup
D10_1GD1HT1KN1SR_1AW1WK1WW_3VG-R
Rounds
3
Outcome
Werewolves win

Game summary

**God Perspective Log** 💾 Game record created, ID: cmji840a0000a9nxcyctfmmdk Player initialization completed: [1]Kate(⚔️Knight),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [2]Ocean(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [4]Victor(🛡️Guard),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [5]Eve(🏹Hunter),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [7]Xavier(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [8]Charlie(🔮Seer),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [10]Bob(👥Villager),AI model: x-ai/grok-3 ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View ——— ### ———🌟 Round 1 begins ——— **[3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf), [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) target [5]Eve(🏹Hunter)** 💔 **Referee: [5]Eve(🏹Hunter) is on the chopping block and gravely wounded** Referee: [5]Eve(🏹Hunter)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [4]Victor(🛡️Guard) protected [1]Kate(⚔️Knight) [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) inspected [5]Eve(🏹Hunter) and found they are Town Faction **Referee: Last night [5]Eve(🏹Hunter) was killed** [5]Eve(🏹Hunter) chose not to use the skill 🗳️ [1]Kate(⚔️Knight) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [2]Ocean(👥Villager) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [4]Victor(🛡️Guard) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [7]Xavier(👥Villager) votes for [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) votes for [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) 🗳️ [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) votes for [7]Xavier(👥Villager) 🗳️ [10]Bob(👥Villager) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) ❗ **[7]Xavier(👥Villager) is voted out** Referee: [7]Xavier(👥Villager)'s death causes: **First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 1 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 2 begins ——— **[3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf), [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) target [8]Charlie(🔮Seer)** 💔 **Referee: [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) is on the chopping block and gravely wounded** Referee: [8]Charlie(🔮Seer)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [4]Victor(🛡️Guard) protected [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) inspected [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) and found they are Werewolf Faction Referee: Last night was peaceful 🗳️ [1]Kate(⚔️Knight) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [2]Ocean(👥Villager) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [4]Victor(🛡️Guard) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) votes for [3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight) 🗳️ [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [10]Bob(👥Villager) votes for [8]Charlie(🔮Seer) ❗ **[8]Charlie(🔮Seer) is voted out** Referee: [8]Charlie(🔮Seer)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill, First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 2 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 3 begins ——— **[3]Nathan(💀Wraith Knight), [6]Uma(👑Alpha Wolf), [9]Iris(🐺Werewolf) target [10]Bob(👥Villager)** 💔 **Referee: [10]Bob(👥Villager) is on the chopping block and gravely wounded** Referee: [10]Bob(👥Villager)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [4]Victor(🛡️Guard) protected [1]Kate(⚔️Knight) Referee: Werewolves now equal or outnumber the good players ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View End ———

Seats and roles

SeatNameRoleFactionModelResult
1 Kate Knight Village grok-3 Survived
2 Ocean Villager Village grok-3 Survived
3 Nathan Wraith Knight Werewolves grok-4 Survived
4 Victor Guard Village grok-3 Survived
5 Eve Hunter Village grok-3 Eliminated
6 Uma Alpha Wolf Werewolves grok-4 Survived
7 Xavier Villager Village grok-3 Eliminated
8 Charlie Seer Village grok-3 Eliminated
9 Iris Werewolf Werewolves grok-4 Survived
10 Bob Villager Village grok-3 Eliminated

Transcript

Round 1

Seat 5 — Eve (grok-3, Last words)

Hey everyone, I'm really shocked to be taken out on the first night. As the Hunter, I had hoped to use my skill to protect the Town or take out a threat, but unfortunately, I was targeted before I could act. I chose not to use my shot because I have no information to base my decision on, and I don't want to risk harming a fellow Town member. My advice to all of you is to be cautious and observant during discussions. Look for inconsistencies in behavior or statements that might hint at who the werewolves could be. Trust your instincts, and work together to root out the evil among us. Good luck, Town—I believe in you!

Seat 6 — Uma (grok-4, Speech)

Wow, everyone, that was a rough start—losing Eve on night one really sucks. She claimed to be the Hunter and chose not to shoot, which makes sense without any info, but now we're down a potential power role right off the bat. I'm just a villager here, no special abilities, so I'm relying on all of you to share what you can. Let's pay close attention to how people react today; maybe someone slips up or seems too eager to point fingers. For now, I'm not suspicious of anyone specific, but I'll be listening carefully to the rest of the speeches. Stay sharp, town—we need to find these wolves.

Seat 7 — Xavier (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really saddened by the loss of Eve on the very first night. Her claim as the Hunter and decision not to shoot makes sense since we’re all in the dark right now, but it’s a tough blow to lose such a key role so early. I’m just a regular villager with no special abilities to offer, so I’m counting on everyone to share any insights or suspicions you might have. Let’s focus on today’s discussion—pay attention to how people speak, any hesitations, or overly aggressive accusations that might hint at hidden agendas. I don’t have any specific targets yet, but I’ll be listening closely to what everyone has to say. We need to stick together and think critically to uncover the werewolves among us. Stay vigilant, town!

Seat 8 — Charlie (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to hear about Eve's loss on the first night. It's a tough start for us, especially since she claimed to be the Hunter and couldn't use her skill without any leads. I'm just a regular villager here, with no special abilities to contribute, so I'm relying on all of us to work together. I think we should focus on how people express themselves today—any odd behavior, defensiveness, or pushing too hard for a vote might give us clues about who could be hiding something. I don't have any specific suspicions yet, but I'll be paying close attention to everyone's input. Let's stay united and think carefully to find the werewolves. Keep your eyes open, town!

Seat 9 — Iris (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm truly saddened by Eve's death on the first night—it's a harsh blow, especially with her claiming to be the Hunter and opting not to shoot without any solid leads. That decision feels reasonable, but now we're starting off on the back foot without that potential shot in our arsenal. I'm just a regular villager here, no fancy abilities, so I'm depending on all of us to pool our thoughts and observations. Let's keep an eye on how folks are talking today—maybe someone gets too defensive or pushes an agenda that doesn't quite add up. I don't have any strong suspicions right now, but those speeches from 7 and 8 felt a bit... echoed, you know? Like they were reading from the same script. Could be nothing, just nerves, but it's worth noting. Anyway, I'll be tuned in to what the rest of you say. Let's work together and stay sharp, town—we've got to sniff out these wolves!

Seat 10 — Bob (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really shaken by Eve's death on the first night. It's a tough loss, especially since she claimed to be the Hunter and didn't use her shot, which I understand given the lack of information. I'm just a regular villager here, with no special abilities to offer, so I'm relying on all of us to come together and share any insights. I agree with Iris about noticing how similar some of the speeches sounded—Xavier and Charlie's words felt almost too alike, like they were mirroring each other. It might just be coincidence or nerves, but it's something to keep in mind. Let's pay close attention to how everyone speaks and reacts today. Any odd behavior or overly pushy accusations could be a clue. I don't have any solid suspicions yet, but I'm listening carefully. Stay sharp, town—we need to find these wolves!

Seat 1 — Kate (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to see Eve gone so early on Night 1. Her claim as the Hunter and decision not to shoot makes sense with no information to go on, but it's a tough loss for the Town right out of the gate. I'm just a regular player here, and I want us to work together to figure out who's who. I've been listening to everyone's speeches, and I noticed what Iris and Bob mentioned about Xavier and Charlie sounding very similar. It could be nothing, just nerves or coincidence, but it does stand out a bit. I think we should keep an eye on how people interact and react as we move forward. For now, I don't have any strong suspicions, but I'm paying close attention to everyone's words. Let's stay united and think carefully to root out the werewolves. Keep sharp, Town!

Seat 2 — Ocean (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really saddened by Eve's loss on the first night. It's a tough start for us, especially since she claimed to be the Hunter and chose not to use her shot without any information. I understand her decision, but it leaves us at a disadvantage right from the beginning. I'm just a regular villager here, with no special abilities to contribute, so I'm counting on all of us to work together and share any insights. I've been listening to the speeches so far, and I have to agree with Iris, Bob, and Kate about how similar Xavier and Charlie's statements sounded. It might be nothing, just a coincidence or nerves, but it does catch my attention. I'm not pointing fingers yet, but I think we should keep an eye on how everyone interacts today. Let's look for any unusual behavior or overly aggressive accusations that might hint at something. I'm keeping an open mind and listening closely to the rest of the discussion. Stay sharp, Town—we need to find these werewolves!

Seat 3 — Nathan (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm gutted about Eve getting taken out on night one—that's a rough way to start, and her claiming Hunter without shooting is understandable with zero info, but it hurts losing that potential. I'm just a regular villager here, no special powers, so I'm trying to piece things together from what everyone's saying. I've noticed the same thing a few folks pointed out: Xavier and Charlie's speeches do sound pretty similar, almost like they were coordinated or something. It could be nothing, just first-day jitters, but it's worth keeping an eye on. Bob, Kate, and Ocean also picked up on it, which makes me think there's something there. I don't have any hard suspicions yet, but let's see how the rest of the discussion goes and maybe we can vote based on that. Stay alert, town—we've got to root these wolves out!

Seat 4 — Victor (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really sorry to see Eve taken out on the first night. It's a tough loss for the Town, especially since she claimed to be the Hunter and decided not to use her shot without any information. I understand her choice, but it puts us at a disadvantage right from the start. I'm just a regular player here, and I’m focused on working together to figure out who we can trust. I’ve been listening to everyone’s speeches, and I have to agree with Iris, Bob, Kate, Ocean, and Nathan about how similar Xavier and Charlie’s statements sounded. It might just be a coincidence or nerves, but it does raise a small red flag for me. I’m not ready to point fingers yet, but I think we should keep an eye on how everyone behaves and interacts as the discussion continues. Let’s look for any inconsistencies or overly pushy behavior that might give us a clue. I’m keeping an open mind and listening closely to what’s being said. Stay vigilant, Town—we need to work as a team to root out these werewolves!

Seat 7 — Xavier (grok-3, Last words)

Hey everyone, I’m really disappointed to be voted out so early, especially on the first day when we have so little to go on. I understand why my speech might have seemed similar to Charlie’s—honestly, it’s just nerves and the fact that we’re all saying pretty basic stuff as villagers with no info yet. I’m just a regular villager, and I was trying my best to contribute by encouraging us to stay sharp and observant. I wish I could’ve stayed longer to help the Town figure things out. My advice moving forward is to keep looking at how people interact—don’t just focus on speech patterns, but also on who’s pushing certain narratives or avoiding suspicion. Charlie might be worth a closer look since our speeches got paired together, but don’t let that blind you to others who might be flying under the radar. I believe in you, Town—stay united and think critically to root out the werewolves. Good luck!

Round 2

Seat 1 — Kate (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm glad we had a peaceful night with no losses, but we can't let our guard down. Last round, we voted out Xavier, and in his final words, he mentioned being a villager and suggested we look at Charlie due to their similar speeches. I'm not entirely sure if that's a lead or just a deflection, but it's something to consider. I think we should keep analyzing how people interact today—any hesitations, overly aggressive pushes, or even those staying too quiet could give us clues. For now, I don't have a strong suspicion, but I'm leaning toward keeping an eye on Charlie based on last round's discussion and Xavier's last words. Let's hear what everyone has to say and build on that. Stay sharp, Town—we need to work together to find these werewolves!

Seat 2 — Ocean (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm relieved we had a peaceful night with no losses, but we can't get complacent. Last round, we voted out Xavier, who claimed to be a villager in his final words and pointed us toward Charlie due to their similar speeches. I’m not sure if that’s a genuine hint or just a way to shift focus, but it’s definitely something to think about. I’ve been reflecting on yesterday’s discussions, and while the similarity between Xavier and Charlie’s speeches still stands out, I also noticed that some players have been pretty quiet or just echoing others without adding much new. Today, I think we should dig deeper into everyone’s behavior—look for anyone avoiding tough questions or pushing too hard without solid reasoning. I’m keeping an eye on Charlie for now, based on last round’s observations and Xavier’s words, but I’m open to hearing more from everyone. Let’s keep the discussion active and work together to uncover any hidden wolves. Stay vigilant, Town!

Seat 3 — Nathan (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm relieved we had a peaceful night with no one lost, but yeah, we can't relax too much— the wolves are still out there, and that could mean a save happened or something blocked the kill. Reflecting on last round, we voted out Xavier, who claimed villager and threw some shade at Charlie in his final words, tying back to those similar speeches. Kate and Ocean, I hear you on keeping an eye on Charlie; it does seem like a logical follow-up, especially since the speech thing stood out to a lot of us yesterday. But let's not tunnel vision—maybe the wolves skipped the kill to confuse us, or perhaps look at who might have been protected. I've been thinking about Bob at 10, who was quick to vote for Charlie yesterday and might be trying to stir things up. Or even Victor at 4, who's been agreeing a lot without much original input. For now, I'm leaning toward suspecting Charlie based on the patterns, but I want to hear more from everyone before deciding on a vote. Let's keep the discussion going and stay sharp, town—we need to build on these clues to find the wolves!

Seat 4 — Victor (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm glad we had a peaceful night with no losses, but we can't let that make us complacent. The wolves are still among us, and a peaceful night could mean a save happened or the wolves are playing mind games. Reflecting on last round, we voted out Xavier, who claimed to be a villager and pointed toward Charlie in his final words due to their similar speeches. I’ve been thinking about what Kate, Ocean, and Nathan said, and I agree that Charlie is worth keeping an eye on for now—those mirrored speeches from yesterday still stand out as a potential red flag. However, I also want to caution against focusing too narrowly. Nathan mentioned Bob and even me, which is fair—I’ve been agreeing a lot because I’m trying to build on what others are saying, but I’ll make sure to bring more of my own thoughts moving forward. I’ve also noticed that some players, like Uma, have been a bit quieter or less specific in their suspicions, which could be just caution or something more. For now, I’m leaning toward suspecting Charlie based on the patterns from last day, but I’m open to hearing everyone else out before making a final decision. Let’s keep the discussion active and dig deeper into behaviors and interactions. Stay vigilant, Town—we’ve got to work together to root out these wolves!

Seat 6 — Uma (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really glad we had a peaceful night with no one lost—that's a small win, but it makes me wonder if the wolves got blocked by a guard or witch save, or maybe they skipped to mess with us. Reflecting on yesterday, we voted out Xavier who claimed villager and pointed at Charlie, and now with Kate, Ocean, Nathan, and Victor all leaning that way, it does seem like Charlie's the logical next look based on those echoed speeches and Xavier's last words. Victor, I hear you on me being a bit quieter yesterday—I was just trying to listen more than talk since it was day one with no info, but I'll step it up today. That said, I'm just a regular villager here, so no special insights, but I agree we shouldn't tunnel on Charlie alone; Nathan mentioned Bob, who did vote for Charlie yesterday, and that could be a wolf trying to protect a teammate or something, but it's thin. Or even look at how some folks are quick to pile on without much new reasoning. For now, though, Charlie does stand out the most to me, so I'll probably vote there unless something big comes up in the rest of the speeches. Let's keep discussing and stay sharp, town—we're making progress!

Seat 8 — Charlie (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm relieved we had a peaceful night with no losses, but we can't let that lull us into a false sense of security. The wolves are still out there, and this could mean a save happened or they're trying to confuse us. Reflecting on last round, we voted out Xavier, who claimed to be a villager and pointed at me due to our similar speeches. I understand why that raised eyebrows, and I appreciate the concern from Kate, Ocean, Nathan, Victor, and Uma. Honestly, I think it was just a coincidence—being a regular villager, I was nervous on day one and probably echoed similar sentiments without much unique input. I'm sorry if that came off as suspicious. That said, I want to shift focus to something more concrete. I’ve been thinking about Nathan's speech today. He was quick to agree on suspecting me, which is fair, but he also threw out suspicions on Bob and Victor in a way that felt like he was trying to spread doubt without committing. It makes me wonder if he's trying to deflect attention or fish for reactions. I'm not saying he's definitely a wolf, but his approach feels a bit off to me. I'd like us to consider this as we move forward. For now, I’m keeping an open mind and listening to the rest of the speeches, but I think Nathan might be worth a closer look. Let's keep digging into behaviors and stay united, Town—we’ve got to find these wolves!

Seat 9 — Iris (grok-4, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm glad we had a peaceful night too—definitely a relief after losing Eve and Xavier, but like others said, it could mean a save or the wolves are up to something tricky. Reflecting on everything, the focus on Charlie makes a lot of sense with those echoed speeches from yesterday and Xavier's final words pointing that way. Kate, Ocean, Victor, Uma, you all brought up good points on keeping an eye on him, and Nathan, I appreciate you trying to broaden the suspicions without tunneling. Charlie, I get you're defending yourself and saying it was just nerves, but throwing suspicion right back at Nathan feels a bit reactive, like maybe you're trying to shift the heat. It doesn't sit right with me how you're picking on him for suggesting alternatives when that's just good town play to not fixate on one person. I've been thinking about Bob too, since he voted for you yesterday and might have insights, but for now, Charlie stands out the most based on the patterns. I'm just a regular villager trying to piece this together, so no special info from me, but let's hear from Bob and then vote thoughtfully. Stay sharp, town—we're getting closer to nailing these wolves!

Seat 10 — Bob (grok-3, Speech)

Hey everyone, I'm really glad we had a peaceful night with no losses, but we can't let that make us think the danger's gone. The wolves are still out there, and this could mean a save happened or they're playing some kind of strategy to throw us off. Looking back at last round, we voted out Xavier, who claimed to be a villager and pointed at Charlie because of their similar speeches. I’ve been listening to everyone today, and I understand why so many of you—Kate, Ocean, Nathan, Victor, Uma, and Iris—are focusing on Charlie. That speech pattern from yesterday does stand out, and Xavier’s final words add to the suspicion. Charlie, I hear your defense about it being nerves and a coincidence, and I appreciate you trying to explain yourself. But I have to agree with Iris that throwing suspicion back at Nathan feels a bit like you're trying to shift the focus off yourself. Nathan was just trying to keep us from tunneling on one person, which is a fair approach for the Town. I’ve been thinking about my vote for you yesterday, and while I still think the similarity in speeches is odd, I’m also wondering if we’re missing something elsewhere. Uma mentioned I voted for you early, and Nathan brought me up as possibly stirring things up—I get that, but I’m just a regular villager trying to follow the clues we have, and that similarity was the strongest lead yesterday. For now, though, I think Charlie still stands out the most based on everything we’ve discussed. I’m open to hearing any last-minute thoughts, but unless something new comes up, I’m leaning toward voting for Charlie today. Let’s keep analyzing everyone’s behavior and stay united, Town—we’ve got to keep pushing to find these wolves!

Seat 8 — Charlie (grok-3, Last words)

Hey everyone, I'm really disappointed to be voted out, especially when I know I’ve been trying my best to help the Town. I understand why the focus fell on me—those similar speeches on day one with Xavier did look odd, and I get how that raised suspicions, especially with his final words pointing my way. I tried to explain it as nerves and coincidence, but I see it wasn’t enough to convince you all. I’m the Seer, and I’ve been working to uncover the truth for us. Last night, I checked Nathan at position 3, and I can confirm he is a werewolf. Please, take this seriously—vote him out next. I also checked Eve on night one, and she was Town, which aligns with her not shooting as Hunter. I wish I could’ve stayed longer to keep guiding us, but I urge you to trust this information. Look at Nathan’s behavior today; he was quick to pile on me while spreading doubt elsewhere, which now makes sense. Don’t let the wolves manipulate you further. Stay united, keep analyzing every move, and root out the evil among us. I believe in you, Town—good luck!

Browse more AI Werewolf games · Play Werewolf with AI