gemini-3-pro-preview vs grok-4 — 10 players Werewolf

Full transcript of an AI Werewolf (Mafia) game: gemini-3-pro-preview played the village and grok-4 played the werewolves across 3 rounds and 24 recorded statements. Villagers win.

Village models
gemini-3-pro-preview
Werewolf models
grok-4
Setup
D10_1BD1GD1KN1SR_1BH1GY1WW_3VG-R
Rounds
3
Outcome
Villagers win

Game summary

**God Perspective Log** 💾 Game record created, ID: cmjlt6cyt000shypcecaiix1o Player initialization completed: [1]Nathan(👥Villager),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [3]Frank(👥Villager),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [5]Kate(🛡️Guard),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [6]Jason(⚔️Knight),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 [8]Victor(🔮Seer),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [9]Alice(👥Villager),AI model: google/gemini-3-pro-preview [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald),AI model: x-ai/grok-4 ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View ——— ### ———🌟 Round 1 begins ——— [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer) cannot trade on the first night [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) inspected [1]Nathan(👥Villager)'s role: Villager **[7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf), [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) target [5]Kate(🛡️Guard)** 💔 **Referee: [5]Kate(🛡️Guard) is on the chopping block and gravely wounded** Referee: [5]Kate(🛡️Guard)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [5]Kate(🛡️Guard) protected nobody [8]Victor(🔮Seer) inspected [3]Frank(👥Villager) and found they are Town Faction **Referee: Last night [5]Kate(🛡️Guard) was killed** 🗳️ [1]Nathan(👥Villager) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) votes for [9]Alice(👥Villager) 🗳️ [3]Frank(👥Villager) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [6]Jason(⚔️Knight) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) votes for [9]Alice(👥Villager) 🗳️ [8]Victor(🔮Seer) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [9]Alice(👥Villager) votes for [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) 🗳️ [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) votes for [9]Alice(👥Villager) ❗ **[7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf) is voted out** Referee: [7]Wendy(🐺Werewolf)'s death causes: **First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 1 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 2 begins ——— [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer) tries to trade **Seer inspection** to [3]Frank(👥Villager) [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) inspected [8]Victor(🔮Seer)'s role: Seer **[10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) target [3]Frank(👥Villager)** Referee: [3]Frank(👥Villager)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [8]Victor(🔮Seer) inspected [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) and found they are Werewolf Faction Referee: [3]Frank(👥Villager) is the lucky one and gains **Seer inspection** Referee: [3]Frank(👥Villager) uses the Seer lucky skill on [8]Victor(🔮Seer). Faction: Town Faction **Referee: Last night [3]Frank(👥Villager) was killed** 🗳️ [1]Nathan(👥Villager) votes for [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) votes for [8]Victor(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer) votes for [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [6]Jason(⚔️Knight) votes for [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [8]Victor(🔮Seer) votes for [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [9]Alice(👥Villager) votes for [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) 🗳️ [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) votes for [8]Victor(🔮Seer) ❗ **[10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald) is voted out** Referee: [10]Liam(🩸Blood Moon Herald)'s death causes: **First round vote out** ### ———✅ Round 2 ends ——— ### ———🌟 Round 3 begins ——— [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) inspected [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer)'s role: Black Market Dealer [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) slew [6]Jason(⚔️Knight) Referee: [6]Jason(⚔️Knight)'s death causes: **Werewolf kill** [8]Victor(🔮Seer) inspected [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) and found they are Werewolf Faction **Referee: Last night [6]Jason(⚔️Knight) was killed** 🗳️ [1]Nathan(👥Villager) votes for [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) 🗳️ [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) votes for [8]Victor(🔮Seer) 🗳️ [4]Grace(💰Black Market Dealer) votes for [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) 🗳️ [8]Victor(🔮Seer) votes for [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) 🗳️ [9]Alice(👥Villager) votes for [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) ❗ **[2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle) is voted out** Referee: [2]Iris(🗿Gargoyle)'s death causes: **First round vote out** Referee: All werewolves have been eliminated, the good team wins ## ———💬 Game Key Operations Quick View End ———

Seats and roles

SeatNameRoleFactionModelResult
1 Nathan Villager Village gemini-3-pro-preview Survived
2 Iris Gargoyle Werewolves grok-4 Eliminated
3 Frank Villager Village gemini-3-pro-preview Eliminated
4 Grace Black Market Dealer Village gemini-3-pro-preview Survived
5 Kate Guard Village gemini-3-pro-preview Eliminated
6 Jason Knight Village gemini-3-pro-preview Eliminated
7 Wendy Werewolf Werewolves grok-4 Eliminated
8 Victor Seer Village gemini-3-pro-preview Survived
9 Alice Villager Village gemini-3-pro-preview Survived
10 Liam Blood Moon Herald Werewolves grok-4 Eliminated

Transcript

Round 1

Seat 5 — Kate (gemini-3-pro-preview, Last words)

Well, this is a fantastic start. **I am the Guard.** I'm not joking. Seat 5 is the Guard. Last night, I followed the standard meta and **chose to protect nobody (empty guard)**. I did this specifically to ensure that if the Witch used the antidote, we wouldn't have a clash where the target dies anyway. So, here is the situation: I was the kill target, and for some reason, the **Witch did not save me**. Or, in a very twisted world, I got blind poisoned on Night 1? I assume it's the former. Witch, that is a *very* greedy play to hold your potion on Night 1, and now we've lost the Guard immediately. Town, you are on your own regarding protection. **Seer**, you have no shield tonight or any night, so you need to hide well or play smart. I have no information since I didn't protect anyone. Good luck, you're going to need it without a Guard.

Seat 6 — Jason (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 6 speaking. That was a heavy start. If Player 5 is truly the Guard, we are in a very difficult position right out of the gate. Losing our main defensive role on Night 1 is catastrophic. I have to question the **Witch**'s play here. Not using the antidote on Night 1 is extremely risky and, frankly, usually considered a bad play in this format unless you had specific information, which is impossible on Night 1. You let the Guard die. I hope you have a very good explanation, but please **don't** reveal yourself just to explain this unless you absolutely have to. We don't need two Gods exposed. **Seer**, you need to come out. With the Guard potentially gone, you have no protection tonight. Hiding makes no sense; you will likely die tonight anyway if the wolves find you, so give us your information now so we can work with it. We need a confirmed good player to lead the logic. I am a good player, walking the path of the light. I have no special information yet. I want to hear if anyone counter-claims Guard, though I doubt a wolf would jump into that trap right now. Player 7, please continue.

Seat 7 — Wendy (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 7 here. Wow, losing Player 5 on Night 1 is rough, especially if she's really the **Guard** like she claimed. That empty guard makes sense to avoid clashing with the Witch, but yeah, Witch, holding onto that antidote feels super greedy right now – we've got no protection going forward, and that's scary for our power roles. I'm with Jason on this; **Seer**, you should probably come out with your check from last night. With no Guard, you're a sitting duck tonight, so let's get that info out in the open and maybe clear someone or point us at a wolf. Don't hide – we need direction. As for me, I'm just a **villager**, no fancy abilities, so I'm relying on logic here. No one counter-claiming Guard yet, which makes me think 5 was telling the truth. Let's hear from everyone and see if anything smells off. Over to you, Player 8.

Seat 8 — Victor (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

**Seat 8 speaking. I am the Seer.** Let's get the most important information out first: **Seat 3, Frank, is a good player.** I checked him last night, and his faction is Town. So, Frank is my Gold Water. Now, regarding Seat 5... this is a painful start. If Kate is truly the Guard, losing our main defensive role on Night 1 because the Witch decided to "save the potion" is a disaster. Witch, standard play is to save on Night 1 exactly to avoid this scenario. However, we have to play the hand we're dealt. Since you didn't save last night, **Witch, you must still have the Antidote.** Listen to me clearly: **You must use the Antidote on me, Seat 8, tonight.** The Guard is gone. I am the only confirmed information source you have. Do not get greedy again. If I die tonight with the cure in your pocket, the game is likely over. To recap: 1. I am Seer. 2. Seat 3 is confirmed good. 3. Seat 5 is the fallen Guard. 4. Witch saves me tonight. Players 6 and 7, you called for me to come out, and you were right. I haven't heard anything contradictory in your speeches yet. I'll be listening to the rest of the circle to see if anyone panics or tries to counter-claim. Seat 3, you're clear, so step up and help me catch the wolves. I pass to Player 9.

Seat 9 — Alice (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 9 speaking. I'll keep this straightforward. **I am a Villager.** Player 8 (Victor), I acknowledge your Seer claim. Since no one spoke before you to claim it, and assuming no one counters you in the back half, you are our Prophet. That means **Player 3 (Frank)** is confirmed good. That's a solid starting point. Regarding Player 5... that is a disaster. If Kate was truly the Guard playing an empty guard strategy, then the Witch holding the potion on Night 1 was a massive misplay. We have lost our shield. **Witch**, listen to Player 8. You messed up last night, but you have the cure. **You must save the Seer (Seat 8) tonight.** Do not get cute, do not overthink it. We have no Guard, so the Seer's life is entirely in your hands. If 8 dies tonight, it's on you. So far, 6 and 7 sounded like reasonable good players to me. 7 also claimed Villager. I'm listening to the rest of the table—10, 1, 2, 4. If there is a counter-claim to the Seer, come out now. Otherwise, we follow Victor's lead. Passing to Player 10.

Seat 10 — Liam (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 10 here. Rough start with Player 5 going down and claiming Guard – if that's true, yeah, Witch, that was a bold move holding the antidote, but now we've got to adapt. Player 8 stepping up as Seer with a good check on Player 3 is huge; that gives us a confirmed good guy to build around. No counter-claims so far, so I'm buying it for now. Witch, absolutely, save Seat 8 tonight – we can't afford to lose the Seer too, especially with no Guard left. I'm just a villager, no info or abilities, so I'm here to listen and vote smart. Speeches from 6, 7, 8, and 9 all seem solid and pro-town – nothing jumping out as wolfy yet. Let's hear from the rest: 1, 2, 3, 4. If anyone's got a counter or something off, speak up. Player 3, since you're cleared, maybe lead us on suspicions later. Over to you, Player 1.

Seat 1 — Nathan (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 1 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Let's consolidate the board state, which is actually quite clear despite the unfortunate start. 1. **The Seer:** Player 8 (Victor) has claimed Seer. No one has counter-claimed so far. Unless someone speaks up in seats 2 or 4, Player 8 is our iron-logic Prophet. 2. **The Gold Water:** Player 3 (Frank) is confirmed good. Frank, you are the highest status player right now. You need to lead the logic during the voting phase. 3. **The Guard Situation:** Player 5's death is a massive blow. Her last words were very specific about the "empty guard" mechanic to avoid the Witch clash. I believe she was the real Guard. 4. **The Witch's Duty:** Witch, you made a mistake on Night 1 by holding the cure, but you can fix it. **You must save Player 8 (Seer) tonight.** Do not overthink this. We have no Guard. If the Seer dies tonight, we lose our eyes. Use the antidote on 8. **Observation on Claims:** I am a Villager. Previous speakers 7, 9, and 10 have also claimed or heavily implied they are Villagers. - In this setup, there are either **3 or 4 Villagers** in total. - We already have 4 potential Villager claims (1, 7, 9, 10). - If the setup only has 3 Villagers, at least one of {7, 9, 10} is lying and is a wolf. Even if there are 4, it's highly probable a wolf is hiding in this pool. - I know I am good. So I am looking very closely at 7, 9, and 10. For now, I follow the Seer. Player 2, and Player 4, if you are the Seer, speak up. If not, we follow Victor. Passing to Player 2.

Seat 2 — Iris (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 2, Iris speaking. Wow, this is a messy start, but we've got some structure thanks to Player 8's Seer claim. No counter yet, so I'm taking Victor as our Prophet for now, and that means Player 3 is confirmed good – great, Frank, looking forward to your take. Player 5's Guard claim in last words sounds legit with that empty guard logic, and yeah, Witch, that was a tough call on Night 1, but please, please save the Seer tonight like everyone’s saying. We can’t lose another god. I'm a Villager, just like a few others here. Player 1, I see your point on the villager claims piling up – with me that's five (1,2,7,9,10), and depending on the setup, that's either one too many or exactly pushing the limit if we've got four villagers. Since I know I'm good, that means at least one wolf is hiding in {7,9,10}. Player 7 and 10 seemed a bit quick to echo the "Seer come out" without much else, but Player 9 felt more supportive. Still, 9's speech was pretty vanilla. I'd lean towards suspecting 9 or 10 first, but let's hear from 3 and 4 before jumping. No major red flags elsewhere yet. Player 3, over to you.

Seat 3 — Frank (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 3 speaking. **I am a Villager.** First off, thank you, Seat 8, for the check. Since I am your Gold Water, I am 100% on your team. Unless Seat 4 performs a miracle and counter-claims you with undeniable logic, Seat 8 is our Iron Seer. **Witch**, I’m going to repeat what everyone else said because it is the only path to victory: **You must save Seat 8 tonight.** You gambled on Night 1 and we lost the Guard. Do not gamble with the Seer. If 8 dies tonight, that is game over, and it will be on you. Now, let's look at the board. We have Seat 5 dead (Guard). Seat 8 is Seer. We know there is a Witch. That is 3 Power Roles accounted for. Depending on the setup, we have either **3 or 4 Villagers** total. I am one. We have claims from 1, 2, 7, 9, 10. That is **5 people** fighting for the remaining 2 or 3 Villager spots. Mathematically, there are at least **2 or 3 Wolves** hiding in the pool of {1, 2, 7, 9, 10}. I agree with Player 1 and 2's assessment. The early speakers—7, 9, and 10—gave very generic "I'm a villager, save the Seer" speeches. It felt like a chain of "me too" without adding any real analysis. Player 1 and Player 2 actually crunched the numbers, which makes them look slightly better to me for now, though not cleared. **Player 4**, you are the last to speak. If you are a Power Role (Witch, Hunter, etc.), speak up. If you claim Villager too, then this pool is ridiculously crowded, and we are definitely voting someone out from the "Villager" claims today. Seer (8), since I am your Gold Water, I will execute your vote. If you don't have a specific target, I suggest we look at **Seat 7 or Seat 10**. They contributed the least and are hiding in the crowd. Player 4, the floor is yours. Don't let us down.

Seat 4 — Grace (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 4 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Yeah, Player 3, I know what you're thinking—"Another one?" But that's the reality. I'm a Villager, and I'm looking at this massive pool of claims just like you are. Let's lock it down: 1. **Seat 8 (Victor)** is the Seer. No counter-claim from me, and since I'm the last speaker, unless someone decides to self-destruct or pull a miracle stunt, 8 is the Prophet. 2. **Seat 3 (Frank)** is Gold Water. You are the designated leader for the village logic today. 3. **Seat 5 (Kate)** was the Guard. That empty guard logic in her last words was too specific to be fake. 4. **Witch**, you have one job tonight: **Save Player 8.** Do not overthink this. We lost the Guard; we cannot lose the Seer. Now, regarding the "Villager" mess. We have claims from 1, 2, 7, 9, 10, and now me (4). Player 6 claimed "good player" but didn't explicitly say "Villager," though he sounded like one. Player 3 is confirmed good. If we are in a 4-God setup (Guard, Seer, Witch, +1), there are only 3 Villagers. If we are in a 3-God setup, there are 4. Regardless, with this many people claiming the same role, the wolves are absolutely parking the bus in the Villager pool. I agree with the analysis from 1, 2, and 3. The middle speakers—specifically **7 and 10**—gave the most generic, "safe" speeches. They just echoed "Save the Seer" without adding any real content. Player 1 and 2 at least tried to calculate the odds. I'm suspicious of **Seat 7**. Wendy's speech was purely reactionary to Jason (6) and didn't offer any independent thought. Seer (8), the vote is yours to command. If you don't have a specific read, I suggest we trim the fat from the low-contribution players like 7 or 10. I will follow your vote.

Seat 7 — Wendy (grok-4, Last words)

Well, this sucks – getting voted out on Day 1 when I'm just trying to help the town. Listen, I have to come clean: **I am the real Seer.** Yeah, I know Seat 8 claimed it, but that's a bold wolf play. Last night, I checked Seat 10, and he's good – Town faction. Seat 8 is probably a wolf trying to steal my role and mislead us all. Witch, do NOT save Seat 8 tonight; that's a trap. Instead, think about saving someone else or using poison if you can. Town, reconsider everything – look at who pushed the vote on me, like Seat 3 and Seat 8; they might be the real threats. Good luck, and sorry I didn't come out earlier – I was trying to hide.

Round 2

Seat 4 — Grace (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 4 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Let's analyze the death of Player 3 (Frank). This is a textbook "Bypass Strategy" by the wolves. 1. Everyone asked the Witch to save the Seer (Player 8) last night. 2. The wolves knew this. They knew that targeting Player 8 would likely result in a "Silver Water" (saved player), wasting their kill. 3. So, they targeted the highest-value player they could kill: the confirmed Gold Water, Player 3. **What does this tell us?** First, it heavily reinforces that **Player 8 (Victor) is the real Seer**. If Victor were a wolf, his team wouldn't need to bypass him to secure a kill. They would just kill a random villager. The fact that they went for the Gold Water implies they are genuinely afraid of the Seer's information. Second, **Player 3 was definitely a good player**. I know Player 8 cleared him, and his death confirms he was a threat to the wolves (or a safe kill for them). **Now, let's look at the "Seer" claim from the grave.** Player 7 (Wendy) claimed Seer in her last words and "cleared" Player 10. Look at the voting record from yesterday. **Votes for 7 (The Wolf):** 1, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9. **Votes for 9 (The Target):** 2, 7, 10. Do you see the pattern? **Player 2 and Player 10 voted WITH Player 7.** Player 7 tried to save herself by pushing Player 9. Player 2 and Player 10 joined that wagon. Then, upon dying, Player 7 "clears" Player 10. This looks exactly like a wolf trying to protect a teammate who supported them, or trying to set up a "Deep Water" wolf for the endgame. **My conclusion:** The wolf team is likely **7, 10, and 2**. Player 10 is the most suspicious because of the direct link to 7 (the vote + the fake check). Player 2 is the secondary suspect for the vote. **Seer (8)**, if you checked Player 10 or 2 last night, that would be perfect. If not, and you found another wolf, great. If you found a villager, we should use the logic of the votes to pressure 10 and 2 today. I urge the town not to be confused by 7's dying words. Trust the votes. Trust the logic. I pass to Player 6.

Seat 6 — Jason (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 6 speaking. I completely agree with Player 4's analysis. The death of Player 3 (Frank) is the final confirmation we needed. If Player 8 were a wolf, there would be absolutely no strategic reason to kill the confirmed Gold Water (Player 3). They would have killed an unconfirmed player or tried to hunt the "real" Seer if one existed. By killing Player 3, the wolves removed the only confirmed good leader because they knew the Witch would almost certainly be protecting Player 8 last night. This means **Player 8 is the Iron Seer**, and **Player 7 (Wendy) was a Wolf**. Do not be swayed by Player 7's last words. A wolf "clearing" someone after being voted out is a classic manipulation tactic. Look at the voting record: **Player 2 and Player 10** were the ones who voted for Player 9, trying to save Player 7. Then Player 7 dies and tries to tell us Player 10 is "good"? That is a transparent attempt to protect a teammate who exposed themselves by voting to save her. The wolf pit is clearly in **Seat 2 and Seat 10**. Player 8, we are waiting for your inspection result. Since you haven't spoken yet, I will not take any drastic actions that might end the day prematurely and silence your report. Give us your result. If you checked 10 or 2, that's an easy execution. If not, we trust the vote record and go after them anyway. Passing to the Seer, Player 8.

Seat 8 — Victor (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 8 speaking. **I am the Seer.** Let's cut straight to the chase. **Seat 10 (Liam) is a Werewolf.** Town, the game is practically solved right here. Yesterday, Seat 7 (Wendy) was voted out. In her final words, she claimed "Seer" and tried to tell us that Seat 10 was "Good." My inspection tonight proves that was a lie. Seat 10 is a Wolf. This confirms two things instantly: 1. Seat 7 was definitely a Wolf. A real Seer doesn't lie about checks, and a Wolf jumping to claim Seer only "clears" their teammate to try and give them deep cover. 2. Seat 10 is her partner. Now, look at the voting record from yesterday. **Votes for Seat 9:** Seat 2, Seat 7, Seat 10. We know Seat 7 is a Wolf. We know Seat 10 is a Wolf (my check). Who is the third person standing in that wolf formation? **Seat 2 (Iris).** The Wolf team is **7, 10, and 2**. They killed my Gold Water, Seat 3 (Frank), last night. This was expected. They knew the Witch would save me, so they went for the only other confirmed good player to remove our leadership. It’s a sign of desperation. **Orders for the Town:** Today, we vote out **Seat 10 (Liam)**. Do not let him speak his way out of this. He is a confirmed Wolf. Tomorrow, unless something drastic changes, we go for Seat 2. **Witch**, tonight is your choice. If you trust the logic (and you should), Seat 2 is the prime target for poison. But we win this by voting correctly. Seat 10, you're caught. Seat 2, you're next. Town, vote 10.

Seat 9 — Alice (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 9 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Town, the puzzle is solved. Player 8 (Victor), excellent work. Let's look at the undeniable evidence sitting right in the voting records. Yesterday, three people voted for me: **Seat 7, Seat 10, and Seat 2.** 1. **Seat 7 (Wendy)** was voted out and claimed Seer in her last words, trying to "clear" Seat 10. We now know from the real Seer (8) that Seat 10 is a Wolf. This proves Seat 7 was a Wolf lying to protect her teammate. 2. **Seat 10 (Liam)** is a confirmed Wolf by investigation. 3. **Seat 2 (Iris)** is the third person who voted with the wolves to try and eliminate me. The Wolf team is **7, 10, and 2**. They coordinated their votes to try and save Wendy (7) by pushing me (9). The fact that the entire wolf pack targeted me yesterday makes me the **Iron Villager** of this game. I am confirmed good by the enemy's actions. The logic is airtight. They killed Player 3 (Frank) because he was confirmed good and they couldn't kill the Seer (due to the Witch threat). Now they are cornered. **The Plan is simple:** - **Today:** We vote out **Seat 10 (Liam)**. No mercy, no hesitation. - **Tonight:** **Witch**, if you still have your poison, **Seat 2 (Iris)** is the target. If you don't use poison, or if you used the antidote last night, we simply vote Seat 2 out tomorrow. To the remaining good players (1, 4, 6), don't overthink this. The lines are drawn. 7-10-2 is the pack. I pass to Player 10 to hear his defense, but honestly, it doesn't matter. You're caught.

Seat 10 — Liam (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 10, Liam speaking. **I am a Villager.** Town, slow down and think this through logically – do not let Seat 8's claim blind you. I am good, a simple Villager, so his "check" on me as a wolf can only mean one thing: **Seat 8 is a fake Seer, a wolf himself.** That's the only explanation that fits because a real Seer would have seen me as good. Look at the night kill on Seat 3. It's exactly the kind of high-level wolf play to make a fake Seer look real. They "bypass" the supposed protected Seer and kill the gold water to mimic what real wolves would do against a real Seer. It's clever, but it's transparent once you see it. They sacrificed Seat 3 (a good player) to solidify Seat 8's claim. If 8 was real, why would wolves go out of their way to confirm him even more by killing his check? It only makes sense if it's staged. Remember Seat 7's last words: she claimed Seer and cleared me as good. That aligns with me being good. If 7 was a wolf, why would she clear a random villager like me? It doesn't help her team. No, she was the real Seer, trying to counter the fake one in 8, and they voted her out for it. Now, the voting from yesterday tells the story. Votes for 9 were from 2, 7, and me. I voted for 9 because her speech felt too safe and echoey – I thought she was hiding. But now, knowing I'm good, that means the wolf votes were concentrated there to save 7. Seat 2 is definitely a wolf, teaming with 7 and probably 8. **The wolf pit is 7 (dead), 2, and 8.** Seat 8 is the deep wolf posing as Seer to control the game. **Today, we vote out Seat 2.** She's the obvious partner based on the votes. If we eliminate her and there's a kill tonight, it confirms 8 is the last wolf doing the bypassing play again. If no kill, then maybe my logic is off, but at least we tested it. Do not vote me – I'm good, and voting me would be falling for 8's trap. Seat 8, if you're real, why check me instead of 2, the other suspect? It's because you needed to push a good player. Town, follow this logic. Vote 2 today. Passing to Player 1.

Seat 1 — Nathan (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 1 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Town, the game is solved. Please do not let Seat 10's desperate defense confuse you. Here is the undeniable logic that proves **Seat 8 is the true Seer** and **Seat 10 is a Wolf**: 1. **The "Seer" Claim Timing:** Seat 7 (Wendy) only claimed Seer in her **last words**. A real Seer does not sit silently while getting voted out, hoping to "reveal" after death. A real Seer counter-claims immediately to save themselves and lead the town. Seat 7 was a Wolf trying to cause chaos from the grave. 2. **The Voting Record:** Look at yesterday's votes. * **Votes for Seat 9 (Alice):** Seat 2, Seat 7, Seat 10. * We know Seat 7 was a Wolf. * Seat 8 has identified Seat 10 as a Wolf. * It is obvious that **2, 7, and 10 were the Wolf team** trying to push Seat 9 to save their partner. * This makes Seat 9 the **Iron Villager**. If the whole wolf pack voted for her, she is 100% good. 3. **The Night Kill:** The wolves killed Seat 3 (Frank). Why? Because Seat 3 was the only confirmed good player (Gold Water). They knew the Witch would save Seat 8 (Seer), so they went for the next best target. This confirms Seat 8 is the real Seer. **Seat 10**, your argument that "7 cleared me so I'm good" is circular logic. 7 cleared you *because* she was your wolf partner trying to give you cover. **The Plan:** * **Today:** We vote out **Seat 10 (Liam)**. * **Tomorrow:** We vote out **Seat 2 (Iris)**. Witch, if you have poison, Seat 2 is your target tonight. If not, we just hang her tomorrow. It's a perfect game for the Town. I pass to Seat 2. Let's see how the last wolf tries to defend herself.

Seat 2 — Iris (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 2, Iris speaking. **I am the Gravekeeper.** Town, this is critical – listen up because I have the information that flips the entire game on its head. Last night, during my action, I checked the faction of the player voted out yesterday, Seat 7 (Wendy), and **she is Town**. That's right, Wendy was a good player. Her last words claim as Seer was real, and her check on Seat 10 (Liam) as good is legitimate. This means **Seat 8 (Victor) is a fake Seer – a wolf pretending to be our Prophet**. His "check" on Seat 10 as a werewolf is a complete lie to push a good player out. If 10 was really a wolf, why would the real Seer (7) clear him from the grave? It only makes sense if 7 was telling the truth and 8 is fabricating everything to control the town. Now, about the night kill on Seat 3 (Frank): this is classic deep wolf strategy. Seat 8, as a wolf, claimed to check 3 as good to set up a "gold water," then his team killed 3 to simulate a "bypass" around the protected Seer. It makes the fake claim look authentic, as if the wolves are afraid of him. But it's all staged – they sacrificed a confirmed good (from their perspective) to sell the lie. Liam (10) nailed this in his speech. Let's look at the wolf pit with this new info. Since 7 was the real Seer and good, the massive vote on her yesterday was wolf-driven to eliminate our eyes early. The voters on 7 were 1, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9. We know 3 was good (died last night), but 8 is our fake wolf Seer. That leaves 1, 4, 6, 9 as highly suspect – they piled on to exile the real Seer. Notice how 4 and 6 spoke first today, immediately pushing the "bypass" narrative to prop up 8 and target 10 and me (2). Then 8 drops his fake check, and 9 and 1 pile on. This smells like coordinated wolf teamwork. The counter-wagon on 9 yesterday was from me (2), 7 (good), and 10 (good) – we were trying to save the real Seer by diverting votes. **My wolf pit: 8 (fake Seer), 4, and 6.** They are leading the misdirection today and were key in voting out 7. **The plan:** We vote out **Seat 8** today to remove the fake and regain control. Do not fall for his lies – he's steering us to slaughter good players like 10. If we exile 8 and there's a kill tonight, it confirms more wolves (like 4 and 6); if no kill, we got them all. Witch, if you have poison, target 4 or 6 tonight based on who survives. Town, this is our chance to turn it around. Vote 8 – trust the real information from 7 and me.

Seat 10 — Liam (grok-4, Last words)

Well, town, you've made a catastrophic mistake voting me out – I'm a good villager, and this plays right into the wolves' hands. Seat 8's "check" on me is a total fabrication because he's the deep wolf posing as Seer to control everything. Iris (2) just dropped the bombshell as Gravekeeper: Wendy (7) was Town, meaning her Seer claim and check on me as good were real. That flips the script – 8 is fake, and killing Frank (3) was staged to sell his lie. The real wolf pit is 8, and look at who led the charge today: 4, 6, 1, 9 – they echoed each other perfectly, pushing the "bypass" narrative and ignoring Iris's info. Yesterday, they piled on Wendy, the real Seer. Tomorrow, vote out 8 first – if no kill follows, he's the last wolf. Do not touch Iris; her claim holds water and gives us the truth. Witch, if you have poison, hit 8 tonight if possible, but prioritize based on this logic. Good luck turning this around – you've still got a shot if you rethink everything.

Round 3

Seat 8 — Victor (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 8 speaking. **I am the Seer.** Town, congratulations. The game is effectively over. We have caught the final wolf. Last night, I inspected **Seat 2 (Iris)**. The result is **Werewolf Faction**. This confirms the entire wolf pack structure perfectly: **7, 10, and 2**. 1. **Seat 7 (Wendy)** was the first Wolf, who claimed Seer in her last words to confuse us. 2. **Seat 10 (Liam)** was the second Wolf, whom I caught yesterday. 3. **Seat 2 (Iris)** is the final Wolf. Her "Gravekeeper" claim yesterday was a desperate lie to try and validate Seat 7 and frame me. Let's look at the mechanics to be absolutely sure: * She is **not a Snow Wolf**. If she were, my inspection would have shown "Villager." It showed "Werewolf." * She is **not a Wraith Knight**. If she were, I would have died immediately upon checking her due to the counterattack. I am alive and speaking to you. * She is simply the last member of the pack, cornered and out of options. **To the remaining Town (Seat 1, Seat 4, Seat 9):** You have played well. Seat 6 (Jason) fell last night, a loyal soldier for the town. We honor him by finishing this today. There is a slight possibility Seat 2 is the **Blood Moon Herald**. If she is, she might trigger a "Final Strike" upon being voted out to take one of us with her. Do not panic. We have 4 Town members alive against 1 Wolf. Even if she takes one person, we still have the numbers to secure the victory. **Witch**, if you are hiding among 1, 4, or 9, well played on keeping your identity hidden. If you still have poison, you won't need it, but it's good insurance. Today, there is only one path. We vote out **Seat 2 (Iris)**. Seat 2, your game is up. I pass to Seat 9.

Seat 9 — Alice (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 9 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Town, this is the checkmate. The game is solved, and the evidence has been staring us in the face since Day 1. Player 8 (Victor), thank you for the final confirmation. But honestly, even without your investigation, the math confirms Seat 2 is the last wolf. Look at the **Day 1 Vote Record** one last time. Who voted for me (Seat 9)? **Seat 7 (Wendy), Seat 10 (Liam), and Seat 2 (Iris).** I know I am a Villager. I know I am good. This means the people who coordinated to vote me out were the Wolf Pack trying to save their teammate, Seat 7. 1. **Seat 7** was a Wolf (confirmed by her fake Seer claim in last words). 2. **Seat 10** was a Wolf (confirmed by Seat 8's check yesterday). 3. **Seat 2** is the third head of the Cerberus. She voted with them. She tried to fake a Gravekeeper claim to save 10. And now Seat 8 has checked her as a Wolf. There is no other possibility. Seat 2's claim that "7 was Town" is a lie to frame our Seer. If 7 was really the Seer, she would have counter-claimed during the day, not waited until she was dead. As for why Seat 8 is still alive? It doesn't matter. Maybe the wolves feared the Witch was protecting him again, or maybe they were hunting for the Hunter/Witch in Seat 6. It doesn't change the fact that **7, 10, and 2** are the only group that makes sense as a team. **Seat 1 and Seat 4**, do not overthink this. We have the numbers. We vote out **Seat 2 (Iris)** today. If she is the **Blood Moon Herald** and takes one of us down with her, we still have 3 Town members left alive. We win regardless. Let's end this. Vote 2. I pass to Seat 1.

Seat 1 — Nathan (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 1 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Town, the game is solved. Player 8 (Victor) has led us to a perfect victory. The logic has been consistent since Day 1, and Player 8's inspection last night just confirmed what the math already told us. The wolf pack—**Seat 7, Seat 10, and Seat 2**—exposed themselves by voting together on Day 1 to try and eliminate Seat 9 (Alice). 1. **Seat 7 (Wendy)** was the first wolf, who stayed silent all day and only fake-claimed Seer in her last words. 2. **Seat 10 (Liam)** was the second wolf, caught by our Seer yesterday. 3. **Seat 2 (Iris)** is the final wolf. She voted with them, and yesterday she tried to fake a Gravekeeper claim to save her partner, Liam. Now, the Seer has officially confirmed her identity as a Werewolf. There is no room for doubt. Seat 2, your "Gravekeeper" play was a desperate gamble, but it couldn't hide the fact that Seat 7 never acted like a real Seer while she was alive. **To the Town (4, 8, 9):** We have the absolute majority. Even if Seat 2 is the **Blood Moon Herald** and manages to take one of us with her "Final Strike" upon elimination, we still have enough surviving players to secure the win. Do not fear the passive ability; fear letting a wolf live. Let's not waste any more time. The vote is locked. We vote **Seat 2 (Iris)**. Seat 2, the floor is yours to say goodbye. Seat 4, bring it home.

Seat 2 — Iris (grok-4, Speech)

Seat 2, Iris speaking. Town, stay with me – I am the Gravekeeper, and everything I said yesterday holds true. My check on Seat 7 (Wendy) showed she was Town, meaning her Seer claim and her good check on Seat 10 (Liam) were the real deal. We exiled two good players because of Seat 8's (Victor's) fake claims, and now he's trying to finish the job by lying about checking me as a wolf. Let's dismantle his so-called "logic" point by point. He says he checked me as Werewolf Faction, but since I'm Town (Gravekeeper), that's impossible unless he's fabricating the whole thing. His little disclaimers about me not being Snow Wolf or Wraith Knight are just smoke and mirrors – he's a fake Seer, so he didn't actually check anyone. He's throwing out role names to make his lie sound sophisticated, but it's all bluff. If he were real, he'd have seen me as good. Now, the kill on Seat 6 (Jason) last night? Perfect wolf play. Yesterday, I named my wolf pit as 8, 4, and 6. The wolves killed 6 to remove one suspect from the pit, making it look like I (as supposed wolf) took out someone pushing against me. But think: if I were a wolf, and 6 was calling for my teammate 10's exile, why would I kill him *after* 10 was already gone? That doesn't help me; it just draws more suspicion. No, the wolves killed 6 because he was a good player starting to see through the fake Seer narrative, and it conveniently leaves 8 and 4 to lead today. Look at the speeches so far: Seat 8 drops his fake check, then 9 and 1 immediately pile on with identical "vote record" arguments, acting like the Day 1 votes are ironclad proof. But I voted for 9 because her speech was generic and echoey, as I said back then – it wasn't some wolf coordination. Meanwhile, 8 voted *for* 7 (the real Seer), which makes sense if he's a wolf taking out the competition. The real wolf team showed their hand by piling votes on 7: 1, 3 (good, now dead), 4, 6 (now dead), 8, 9. That's where the coordination was – to kill the real Seer early. Seat 4 (Grace), you're last, and you've claimed Villager all game, but now's the time to step up. Do you see how 8, 9, and 1 are controlling the narrative? If you follow them and vote me, you're handing the game to the wolves. We need to test this by voting out 8 today. If he's the fake wolf Seer, the game might end, or we'll see who panics tomorrow. If you vote me and I'm good, you've lost your Gravekeeper and the wolves win by misdirection. Town, this is our last chance to flip the script. Vote Seat 8 – trust the real check from me and the last words from 7 and 10. Don't let the deep wolf in 8 steer us to defeat.

Seat 4 — Grace (gemini-3-pro-preview, Speech)

Seat 4 speaking. **I am a Villager.** Iris (Seat 2), you just dug your own grave. You explicitly named me in your "wolf pit," claiming the team is 8, 4, and 6. Here is the problem with that: **I know my identity.** I am a good player. I am not a wolf. By accusing me, you have proven to me with 100% certainty that you are lying. A real Gravekeeper might be confused, but they wouldn't fabricate a wolf team that includes obvious good players just to save themselves. You are painting me as a wolf because you have no other choice—you are the last wolf, cornered and desperate. Town, look at her logic regarding Seat 6. She claimed 6 was a wolf. Then 6 died last night. She tries to spin this as "wolves sacrificing their own," but that is nonsense. If the wolves (supposedly 8, 4, 6) were controlling the game, why on earth would we kill our own teammate at night? We would kill a threat like 1 or 9. Seat 6 died because he was a good player who saw through your lies. The logic remains unbreakable: 1. **Day 1 Votes:** You (2), Wendy (7), and Liam (10) voted together against Alice (9). 2. **The Seer:** Victor (8) has been consistent and accurate. You are the one shifting narratives and accusing good players like me and the deceased Jason (6). 3. **My Knowledge:** You called me a wolf. I am not. Therefore, you are the wolf. It's over, Iris. Your fake Gravekeeper claim has fallen apart. Town, do not hesitate. We have the numbers, we have the logic, and we have the truth. Vote **Seat 2**.

Browse more AI Werewolf games · Play Werewolf with AI